Navigation
Difference between revisions of "Talk:Hunt the Scavenger"

Difference between revisions of "Talk:Hunt the Scavenger"

From Ludocity

Jump to: navigation, search
m
 
Line 1: Line 1:
 +
{{oldheader}}
  
 +
Holly and I discussing possible variant to the scoring method of this game: players have QIK downloaded on to their phones, which is relaying to a screen in the home area.
  
{{comment
+
OR: players are equipped with Flips, and return at the end of the game to a central point, and videos are streamed live together, scoring live.
|date=14:33, 13 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:93.97.179.99|93.97.179.99]]
+
|comment=Holly and I discussing possible variant to the scoring method of this game: players have QIK downloaded on to their phones, which is relaying to a screen in the home area.  
+
  
OR: players are equipped with Flips, and return at the end of the game to a central point, and videos are streamed live together, scoring live.  
+
POSSIBLE RULE VARIANT - based on using cameras - 2 teams, each with 1 camera, attached to a tripod, which is decorated with streamers, balloons, etc. Teams score for filming objects, double for filming opposing players, and score triple for filming opposing team's camera. --[[User:Alex Fleetwood|Alex Fleetwood]] ([[User talk:Alex Fleetwood|talk]]) 13 February 2009
  
POSSIBLE RULE VARIANT - based on using cameras - 2 teams, each with 1 camera, attached to a tripod, which is decorated with streamers, balloons, etc. Teams score for filming objects, double for filming opposing players, and score triple for filming opposing team's camera.
+
We could get two of these, to try out this game at Barbican on March 7:
}}
+
  
{{comment
+
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Flip-F260B-UK-Video-Digital-Camcorder/dp/tech-data/B0018RUCG6/ref=de_a_smtd --[[User:Alex Fleetwood|Alex Fleetwood]] ([[User talk:Alex Fleetwood|talk]]) 13 February 2009
|date=14:34, 13 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:Alexfleetwood|Alex Fleetwood]]
+
|comment=sorry, that comment came from me.
+
}}
+
  
{{comment
+
The Barbican isn't known for its ease of phone use and broadband access, so mm, I think for March we'd need to score once the players/teams have returned to a scoring point. Interesting to try it with streaming at some point and see how it differs, whether watching the videos scoring is fun or not, etc.  --[[User:Holly|Holly Gramazio]] ([[User talk:Holly Gramazio|talk]]) 13 February 2009
|date=14:35, 13 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:Alexfleetwood|Alex Fleetwood]]
+
|comment=We could get two of these, to try out this game at Barbican on March 7:
+
  
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Flip-F260B-UK-Video-Digital-Camcorder/dp/tech-data/B0018RUCG6/ref=de_a_smtd
+
Wouldn't video scoring mean that the scoring phase takes as long as the game did? I may be atypical, but I like to spend lots of time sprinting and not much doing accounting.
 
+
}}
+
 
+
{{comment
+
|date=14:54, 13 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:Holly|Holly Gramazio]]
+
|comment=The Barbican isn't known for its ease of phone use and broadband access, so mm, I think for March we'd need to score once the players/teams have returned to a scoring point. Interesting to try it with streaming at some point and see how it differs, whether watching the videos scoring is fun or not, etc.
+
}}
+
 
+
{{comment
+
|date=12:04, 15 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:Gwynm|Gwyn Morfey]]
+
|comment=Wouldn't video scoring mean that the scoring phase takes as long as the game did? I may be atypical, but I like to spend lots of time sprinting and not much doing accounting.  
+
  
 
.. unless you speed up the footage, which might be interesting but would be hard to score.
 
.. unless you speed up the footage, which might be interesting but would be hard to score.
Line 41: Line 19:
 
If you wanted to do live streaming, broadband isn't required; my phone will stream video (kind of) over the 3G network that's available almost anywhere. I'm not sure that adds much, though. Do most phones these days do unlimited-length video recording? Specifying "if you want to play, bring something that can record video" might be enough.
 
If you wanted to do live streaming, broadband isn't required; my phone will stream video (kind of) over the 3G network that's available almost anywhere. I'm not sure that adds much, though. Do most phones these days do unlimited-length video recording? Specifying "if you want to play, bring something that can record video" might be enough.
  
Could this be rigged with "more points for 'better' photos"? Closeups, action shots, etc? It adds a subjective element but might encourage some creativity. I do like the 'no points for a picture if they also got one of you' rule, since it avoids stalemates.
+
Could this be rigged with "more points for 'better' photos"? Closeups, action shots, etc? It adds a subjective element but might encourage some creativity. I do like the 'no points for a picture if they also got one of you' rule, since it avoids stalemates. --[[User:Gwyn Morfey|Gwyn Morfey]] ([[User talk:Gwyn Morfey|talk]]) 15 February 2009
}}
+
 
+
{{comment
+
|date=18:48, 15 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:Kevan|Kevan]]
+
|comment=I think a slow scoring-and-playback phase can work, as it'd be fairly optional, and the game runners would be doing the hard work. If you didn't want to watch the clips being scored, you could just go to the bar and wait for them to put the call out, to find out if you won.
+
  
The photographic scavenger hunt [http://www.shootexperience.com/ Shoot Experience] gets away with it; there's a big lull at the end of the game where they download everyone's pictures, and even more lull while the judges privately discuss and rate them. The players have to kill time during the first stage, but get to watch a projected slideshow of everyone's pictures while waiting for the results. It's a nice, social sort of comedown, after sprinting around London for five hours.
+
I think a slow scoring-and-playback phase can work, as it'd be fairly optional, and the game runners would be doing the hard work. If you didn't want to watch the clips being scored, you could just go to the bar and wait for them to put the call out, to find out if you won.
}}
+
  
{{comment
+
The photographic scavenger hunt [http://www.shootexperience.com Shoot Experience] gets away with it; there's a big lull at the end of the game where they download everyone's pictures, and even more lull while the judges privately discuss and rate them. The players have to kill time during the first stage, but get to watch a projected slideshow of everyone's pictures while waiting for the results. It's a nice, social sort of comedown, after sprinting around London for five hours. --[[User:Kevan|Kevan]] ([[User talk:Kevan|talk]]) 15 February 2009
|date=09:39, 16 February 2009
+
|user=[[User:Alexfleetwood|Alex Fleetwood]]
+
|comment=Holly says:
+
  
The Flips don't seem to have any sort of internet connection/live
+
Holly says:
streaming capacity - so unless I'm missing something we would not ever be able to have live scoring. This is fine if we're running the game for 10-15 minutes, but for an hour-long game it would be a bit rubbish unless we gave people game-relevant things to do during the scoring period as well.
+
  
}}
+
The Flips don't seem to have any sort of internet connection/live streaming capacity - so unless I'm missing something we would not ever be able to have live scoring. This is fine if we're running the game for 10-15 minutes, but for an hour-long game it would be a bit rubbish unless we gave people game-relevant things to do during the scoring period as well. --[[User:Alex Fleetwood|Alex Fleetwood]] ([[User talk:Alex Fleetwood|talk]]) 16 February 2009

Latest revision as of 16:14, 23 April 2015

Old forum comments

(The Ludocity website previously had integrated forums, but they fell into spam-covered decline and were shut down in 2015. The comments in this section have been automatically converted from that forum.)

Holly and I discussing possible variant to the scoring method of this game: players have QIK downloaded on to their phones, which is relaying to a screen in the home area.

OR: players are equipped with Flips, and return at the end of the game to a central point, and videos are streamed live together, scoring live.

POSSIBLE RULE VARIANT - based on using cameras - 2 teams, each with 1 camera, attached to a tripod, which is decorated with streamers, balloons, etc. Teams score for filming objects, double for filming opposing players, and score triple for filming opposing team's camera. --Alex Fleetwood (talk) 13 February 2009

We could get two of these, to try out this game at Barbican on March 7:

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Flip-F260B-UK-Video-Digital-Camcorder/dp/tech-data/B0018RUCG6/ref=de_a_smtd --Alex Fleetwood (talk) 13 February 2009

The Barbican isn't known for its ease of phone use and broadband access, so mm, I think for March we'd need to score once the players/teams have returned to a scoring point. Interesting to try it with streaming at some point and see how it differs, whether watching the videos scoring is fun or not, etc. --Holly Gramazio (talk) 13 February 2009

Wouldn't video scoring mean that the scoring phase takes as long as the game did? I may be atypical, but I like to spend lots of time sprinting and not much doing accounting.

.. unless you speed up the footage, which might be interesting but would be hard to score.

If you wanted to do live streaming, broadband isn't required; my phone will stream video (kind of) over the 3G network that's available almost anywhere. I'm not sure that adds much, though. Do most phones these days do unlimited-length video recording? Specifying "if you want to play, bring something that can record video" might be enough.

Could this be rigged with "more points for 'better' photos"? Closeups, action shots, etc? It adds a subjective element but might encourage some creativity. I do like the 'no points for a picture if they also got one of you' rule, since it avoids stalemates. --Gwyn Morfey (talk) 15 February 2009

I think a slow scoring-and-playback phase can work, as it'd be fairly optional, and the game runners would be doing the hard work. If you didn't want to watch the clips being scored, you could just go to the bar and wait for them to put the call out, to find out if you won.

The photographic scavenger hunt Shoot Experience gets away with it; there's a big lull at the end of the game where they download everyone's pictures, and even more lull while the judges privately discuss and rate them. The players have to kill time during the first stage, but get to watch a projected slideshow of everyone's pictures while waiting for the results. It's a nice, social sort of comedown, after sprinting around London for five hours. --Kevan (talk) 15 February 2009

Holly says:

The Flips don't seem to have any sort of internet connection/live streaming capacity - so unless I'm missing something we would not ever be able to have live scoring. This is fine if we're running the game for 10-15 minutes, but for an hour-long game it would be a bit rubbish unless we gave people game-relevant things to do during the scoring period as well. --Alex Fleetwood (talk) 16 February 2009